Immigration Policy and Politics: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
By HHR | July 31st, 2010 | Category: Featured, Politics | No Comments »
In April the state of Arizona enacted a now famous statute that would make it a crime for immigrants not to carry immigration documents. The proposed new law would have given the police the authority to check for such papers if an officer stopped someone for any reason, such as a traffic violation or even just suspicious behavior. Opponents have argued that it is an invitation to harassment of Latinos and ethnic profiling , which it probably is. The Obama Administration took extraordinary steps of challenging the Arizona law in court, and recently won a partial victory, undoing the law’s most controversial provisions .
In arguing its case, the Justice Department charged that the Arizona usurped federal authority to control immigration. There is no little irony here, since – with 12 million or so illegals living in the United States – the federal government is clearly not controlling immigration. Arizonans and other citizens of border states are increasingly the victims of violent drug gangs and immigrant smuggling cartels. Border state police and social services are strained to the breaking point. Does the federal government really have the right not to control our borders and keep the states from doing so?
Since Washington is not doing its job to secure the borders, shouldn’t it be the states that are suing the federal government, and not the reverse?







