The Arrogance & Hypocrisy of the “Fake Protestors” Charge

mail31 By Charles Badger

After eight years of Cindy Sheehan, Code Pink, Congressmen arrested outside embassies, and other anti-war, anti-globalization, anti- Bush protests, it was easy to get the impression that liberals love to protest. It seems like the Saul Alinsky way-”How to Be an Activist 101.” You have to cause a scene, right? Wrong.  Now Democrats tell us a citizen being disruptive is suspect. Good citizens don’t engage in collective action to make their voices heard to their elected officials. Such outbursts, we are told, can only be explained by the existence of outside forces instigating, funding, and inciting citizens to action.

For proof, one need only look to the recent proliferation of protests at Congressional town-halls. Keith Oberman and Rachel Maddow dismissed those participating are “fake protestors.” Nancy Pelosi called them “Astroturf” and Barbara Boxer said they were too “well-dressed” to be authentic. House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said no “real citizen” would heckle. And several news outlets and commentators repeatedly insist that some unspecified number of these protestors (they never say how many) aren’t from the district represented by the Congressman they’re heckling. The DNC leads the charge on that one. These “grassroots protests” their recent memo asserts-with ‘grassroots’ in sardonic quotation marks-”are being organized and largely paid for by Washington special interests and insurance companies.”

Upon hearing this I couldn’t help but note the parallel between these assertions and those recently put forth by President Ahmadinejad of Iran about his own domestic unrest. Throughout the post-election uprising in his country Ahmadinejad has had one consistent refrain: the West is behind it. Those aren’t really protestors in the streets, Ahmadinejad insists. Rather, they are puppets of Western governments, propagandized by Western media, and instigated by the CIA.

So, too, when American Democrats are faced with protests, such as these and the Tea Parties earlier this year, their solution is to discredit the protestors. We are told these are “fake” citizens biologically engineered in laboratories funded by Big Business and planted by “Right Wing” corporate interests.

But a still more salient contrast struck me upon reflecting on this “fake protestors” assertion. Ahmadinejad wasn’t the first leader to attribute popular movements of citizens to “meddling” outside forces. Indeed, every leader throughout time pursuing an agenda counter to the wishes of the people trots out this stale, hackneyed charge. At the height of the American Civil Rights Movement we saw precisely this assertion parroted by every Southern segregationist mayor and governor. “Northern agitators!” they railed. They were behind the sit-ins and marches and voter registration drives. “We know how to handle our ‘nigras’ here,” Alabama Governor George Wallace remarked. “Those agitators up North don’t know anything about the folks here.”

Hoyer, Boxer, Oberman, and crew sound like Southern mayors in 1960 saying: “Movement? What movement? All the Negroes are happy here.” This deranged delusion led them to convince themselves that segregation would last “today…tomorrow…and forever” as, George Wallace famously proclaimed. Just as the out-of-touch demagogues of the Jim Crow South and today’s tyrannical Iran prove themselves woefully unable to detect a genuine popular movement afoot in their midst, so too, today’s Democratic leaders are fast barreling down a course toward the same fate.

Each time Democrats insist we trust them instead of our “lying eyes” watching images of their constituents staging an overthrow of their power, they continue to demonstrate how clueless they are. It represents both a spirit of hubris and a state of denial-the ingredients which always precede a great fall. Happy midterm elections, Dems!

Charles Badger is sophomore at Berea College in Berea, Kentucky. He was a White House Intern in the summer of 2008, appointed McCain campaign Youth Co-Chairman for Kentucky for the 2008 election and serves as Vice-Chairman of the Kentucky Federation of College Republicans. Charles also works on issues of juvenile crime and prison reform as an appointee of the Governor to the Kentucky Juvenile Justice Advisory Board. At Berea, Charles chairs the campus chapter of College Republicans, is Editor-In-Chief of the student newspaper, and Speaker of the Student Government Association Senate. Charles was born in Queens, New York and now lives in Nashville, TN.

9 comments
Leave a comment »

  1. WORD.

  2. Mr. Badger,
    You are dead on right about this. I expressed a very similiar post on my blog and it doesn’t surprise me that many people feel this way. It is very surprising to me that the liberals think they can rally a majority of Americans to support them by characterizing the protestors in this manner. I really don’t think that they see or understand the implication of their choices. The next time there is a conservative majority and there is something they are strongly opposed to do they really think there will be much credence given to their “grassroots” protests? I think they are shooting themselves in their collective feet on this one and I can’t wait to see it blow up in their faces.

    Charley Helvy

  3. Contrast President Obama and his administrations reaction with that of Bush’s when people were protesting the Iraq war and the Patriot Act. If I remember correctly, President Bush, whenever asked about the protests and Cindy Sheehan in particular, never denigrated or belittled them. He talked about how great our country was and how wonderful freedom of speech was. And didn’t he send two people from his administration out to talk to Cindy Sheehan when she was camped outside his ranch?

  4. Barack Chaves Obama or is it Barach Fidel Obama? I forget!

  5. Excellent, excellent article, Charles.
    You need to update your bio information to say you are now a junior at BC and President of the student union. I’m looking forward to a great senior year with you at the helm!

  6. President Bush respected the dissent of the people. Obama doesn’t. Its really that simple.

  7. I don’t trust either Republicans or Democrats… Both sides have lobbyists paying them off. With enough money in this country, you can get anything done. I lost my faith in the U.S. government months ago. It’s not really Democrat or Republican, as much as it is old-money, greedy bastards who will always get their way.

    As far as the “fake protestors” that is a part of American history that keeps popping up. Lobbyist firms have forged documents on the behalf of the NAACP and other organizations and sent them to Congressmen, so the idea of them paying off counter-protesters isn’t as far fetched as it sounds. I’m tired of the finger pointing on both sides…

  8. your Minor Diety GWB, he of the unnecessary Iraq war, would “stock” the Townhalls w/partisan supporters so there were no Hardball Questions…..Disingenuous at best bubalah!

  9. Democrats were protestsing and making claims before the war, also I live in NYC, and Democrats do the same thing they fill the rooom with supporters from email listervs so to assure that there are no what did you say oohh..yeah “Hardball Questions”…..bubalah!

Leave Comment