Getting Rid of the “Carlton Banks” Stereotype of Black Republicans

__2006_0220february_02_pictures_0720extra20pic20newBy Vanessa

One of the greatest shows in all of sitcom history is probably “The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air”. Remember Carlton Banks (played by Alfonso Rebiero)? He was the quintessential Black Republican! He was rich, out of touch with his consciousness, and surrounded by white people who loved to sing Tom Jones.

Growing up in the 90s, I always thought Carlton’s antics were hilarious-but I never realized the insidious message that I internalized about Black Republicans until I became one, and became the object of peoples’ subtle and not so subtle disapproval. Whenever people find out that I am a Republican, they are usually shocked because of my dreadlocks, and my conscious vibe. After finding out that I recently switched political parties, one of my co-workers befuddled asked, “But…but…you have dreadlocks in your hair, you talk about BLACK HISTORY, and you listen to my problems??”

The reason why he was shocked is because I don’t fit the stereotype of a Black Republican. The image that usually comes to mind when one thinks of a Black Republican is someone who is out of touch with their “blackness” and trying hard to emulate “White America”. Carlton Banks went to private school. He rarely ever danced to Hip Hop, and always had that ever popular awkward Carlton dance where he would snap his fingers and sway his arms from left to right. Carlton spoke proper English, and didn’t hang out with “no brothers”. He looked down at Will’s more ghetto friend Jazzy Jeff. He didn’t listen to Rap, wore khaki pants, and polo shirts and was rarely, if ever on the basketball courts. He was usually playing golf, tennis, or swimming in his pool with his white friends. He was a prominent member of the Republican club in school. He didn’t have what Harry Reid (currently the poster child for racial sensitivity) would call “typical negro dialect.”

In contrast Will Smith’s character was oh so cool, comical, conscious, and down to earth. He fit the prototypical image of a regular brother whose funny and ‘down with the cause’ vibe made everyone feel comfortable and safe.

So, is there an “image” problem for Black Republicans? Of course! That’s without question. Now, if we’re serious about getting more Blacks to the join the side with family values, educational choice options, and economic principles for success, we have to confront our issues as Black Republicans. Many young, conscious, educated Blacks are leaving the Democratic Party and becoming Independents because they realize how much Liberals have monopolized the Black community. There’s a huge constituency of intellectuals that we can convince to join the “right side”. The only problem is most people wouldn’t want to identify themselves as a Carlton Banks. Neither would I.

One of the first things we can do as Black Republicans to tap into this constituency is to start talking about Black Conservatives like Booker T. Washington, Frederick Douglas, Madam CJ Walker, and Mary McLeod Bethune. We can contrast their solutions for Black America with the current Black “leaders” (Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton) who are simply opportunists who don’t care about urban revitalization.

 

We NEED to have to an identity. It’s not enough to parrot mainstream conservatism and expect it to resonate with our people. When I first became an avid Conservative- I began to parrot mainstream conservatism and honestly lost my identity. I slowly began to realize that there’s rhetoric on both sides. What solutions are we bringing to the table? The Tea Party Protestors aren’t thinking about the inner city. They’re fighting for their own causes and they have every right to do so. What are we doing to help Black America? We’ve come a long way and the last thing most Black People want to do is join a Party they think will make them lose their identity.

This is why leaders like Michael Steele are vital. He’s trying to modernize and soften the image of the GOP. Some may say he is “compromising principles” I say he’s reaching across the aisle and drafting pragmatic solutions. We can criticize him, and Obama (like I’ve done), but what are we doing that’s solution-oriented in nature?

Times are changing, the issues are evolving. Talking about “limited government” is one thing. However, enlightening people about the dangers of confiscatory government regulation and how that can effect job creation is something else. As Black Republicans, we shouldn’t be afraid to talk about Racism. It’s not dead. We can acknowledge racism and condemn it, without becoming the liberal establishment victims that typical leftists prey on. There are many people who want us to look the other way and sometimes we do for fear of reprisal. We know how much we’re readily rejected by people who look like us, so we’re scared to rock the boat with White Conservatives. So, we look the other way when we know something is racist and wrong. There are also some who want us to forget our history, heritage, and culture so we can make them feel more comfortable around us. If the shoe was on the other foot, would you have respect for people you perceived to be that way?

If we don’t curtail our strategies, we won’t be able to get Black people to open their ears to the conservative solutions we may have for the inner city. Don’t be afraid to be yourself. I have to constantly remind myself of that. You may not please everyone as a Black Republican, because we’re called “RINOS” on one side, and then we’re called “Uncle Toms” or “Aunt Jemimas” on the other side. Who the hell cares? I’ve found that most people respect people who are honest and true to themselves. And guess what? We can agree to disagree. Frederick Douglas said it best when he said, “I prefer to be true to myself, even at the hazard of incurring the ridicule of others, rather than to be false, and to incur my own abhorrence.”

 
Vanessa better known as the “afroconservative”, has been working in the inner city as a school counselor for the last several years.She is a self-described “urban conservative” who believes in strong families, school choice vouchers, and fiscal policies that help lift people out of poverty-not perpetuate deleterious cycles of government dependence. Vanessa holds a Master’s degree in Counseling but she is currently working towards a second Master’s Degree in Political Economy.
vanessa@afroconservative.com

3 comments
Leave a comment »

  1. I am white, and I wouldn’t want to be like Carlton either. I don’t think it is a black thing, it is a common sense thing.

  2. Great post. Though I’m also a conservative Republican, I grudgingly admit the Democrats are more willing to talk about race. To be fair, a lot of Republicans adopt post-racialism to distance themselves from David Duke & his ilk. That’s a laudable goal. But it drives me nuts to hear someone claim “I don’t even notice skin color.”

    Really?

    That’s like a leftist claiming “I don’t care about your religion, they’re all equally stupid. So we’re going to store pigs in your mosque, comrade.”

    A lot of people have religious traditions that seem strange to others. But as a person of faith, I respect the differences in other religions.

    We need secularism instead of atheism or theocracy. Most Republicans already understand this.

    We need civil rights instead of color-blindness or institutional racism. More Republicans need to understand this.

    And boy, would it be great if Republicans would engage with the question of what civil rights are. They’re the only ones who seem to care about economic freedom.

  3. It is interesting running across this website. My opinion is late but I will leave it anyway. The truth is that I agree with many of the principles you all embrace, fiscally and, to some degree, socially. Nevertheless, I vote for the left and always have. Not because I cannot think for myself but as a lesbian AND black, I sometimes feel the Republicans (black OR white) have no respect for my very humanity. It is absurd to suggest that gays do not have family values like everyone else. We have faith, family values, goals and ambition just like you all. However, from where I sit, hypocrisy is the order of the day every day in your party. You don’t want to the lunatic fringe on the right (and you might as well admit that the lunatic fringe of the Republican party is racist at it’s core even if the rest are…I don’t know…neutral) to discriminate against you within your own party with little or no condemnation. At least with the Dems, though it may be somewhat diminished at times, I do have a voice.

    I really wish I could have a conversation with an actual black Republican who is not Carlton like and does not ignore the virtually unchecked bias within the party. I feel like I would be trying to reason with the KKK if I were to vote for ANY Republican. We are not pervs as is perceived by the right in general. I am someone’s mother, daughter, sister, aunt and spouse just like you folks. I want my civil rights respected the same as you would demand for yourselves and I want to be protected by the law like every one else. If I felt I could have that with the Republicans, I think I’d be willing to take a serious look switching parties. If I have to accept the lesser of two evils, I’m going to choose the one where I am, at least, respected as a human being. Sounds crazy I know but that’s my two cents. Moreover, should anyone respond to this, try to keep it civil.

    Thanks!
    Shan

Leave Comment