Can Social Conservatives Woo Blacks To the GOP ?

ph20090427035141By Richard Ivory:

For decades, social conservatives have relentlessly targeted Black Churches as a way to bring more African-Americans into the Republican Party. Despite many sincere efforts, the numbers of church going African-Americans who vote Republican is smaller now than ever before.

While there has been much debate and talk about the Religious Right within the Republican Party, one could equally and strongly argue that African-Americans make up one of the largest socially conservative voting blocs in the Democrat Party. Earlier this year, the Pew Research Center’s Forum on Religion & Public Life released a detailed study on the religious views of most African-Americans. The research was unique in that the new analysis found blacks to be the most religious group of people in the United States population as a whole.

According to the research, when compared to other racial and ethnic black-church-goersgroups, African-Americans are among the most likely to report a formal religious affiliation with 87% of African-Americans describing themselves as belonging to one religious group or another. The analysis also finds that nearly eight-in-ten African-Americans (79%) say religion is very important in their lives compared with 56% among all U.S. adults.

The study also states that six-in-ten African-Americans (61%) say Houses of Worship should express their views on social and political matters, while only 36% of African-Americans say churches should avoid these topics. On this question of expression, African-Americans closely resemble White Evangelical Protestants, among whom 59% say churches should express their views while 38% say churches should keep out of social and political matters.

The study finds, additionally, that half of all African-Americans feel that there have been too few expressions of faith by political leaders while an additional 24% say there has been the right amount of religious expression by political leaders. Only 23% of African-Americans say there has been too much religious talk from politicians.

Overall, 49% of African-Americans are in favor of keeping abortion legal in most or all cases, while 44% of African-Americans want abortion to be illegal in most or all cases.

Four-in-ten African-Americans (41%) overall, think that homosexuality should be accepted by society, while 46% of African-Americans say that homosexuality should be discouraged. According to other Pew Research Center surveys, conducted during the summer of 2008, nearly two-thirds of African-Americans (64%) say they oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally, which is a significantly higher level of opposition than among Whites (51%).

 If the numbers are correct, African-Americans should be running into the arms of Republicans and, especially, socially conservative ones. The same data, nevertheless, shows that despite African-American’s deep social conservative beliefs, the community does not as a whole “vote exclusively” on such issues.

Proof of this is in the same data which demonstrates that despite their conservative, social view, by far African-Americans (76%) self describe themselves as Democrats. The same study found that on an average, only about 10% of African-Americans self describe themselves as being Republicans. Across all religious groups, at least two-thirds of African-Americans express support for the Democratic Party.

My own personal view of the data is that while African- Americans agree with social conservative politicians on many issues, it is concerning the issue of race, social justice and economics that these two groups part company.

With regards race, many blacks who lived in the South remembered that many of the leaders of the Moral Majority had deep connections to the Southern Baptist Convention. The SBC’s racist history and its deep connections to the GOP in the 80′s had a great impact on black church members. The SBC’s silence during the Jim Crow Era and during the era of Desegregation was not to be forgotten.

This divide in the south between black churches and white churches is still visible today. It was not surprising, therefore, that when the Religious Right began to grow in political dominance in The Republican Party on a wave of pro- family values that many blacks saw this as the height of hypocrisy and irony given the following:

Where were these ministers who were so outraged over the issue of abortion when little Black Boys were being lynched and denied the right to vote?

Where were these same religious leaders and politicians when their Black and socially conservative brothers were suffering?

Historically, social conservatives have talked about “teaching folks how to fish” but have very little to show for it. In fact, most of the non-profit empowerment groups in minority and urban areas lean toward the left. Social conservative groups will continue to fail in reaching black churches as long as urban folks and minorities worry about getting a job and putting food on their tables.

Views about tax cuts  make little sense to a woman who does not pay taxes due to her low -income status. The only way tax cuts will ever make genuine sense to a woman like her is if she owns something or is employed. When the cupboards are bare, and the baby needs milk technical debates about stem cell research or gay marriage will rarely be a priority.

In California, the only way social conservatives could get Blacks out to vote against Proposition 8 was by getting them to come out in large enough numbers to vote for Barrack Obama. What this dichotomy demonstrates is that many minorities agree with social conservatives on many social issues, yet not to the degree that minorities prioritize economic and social justice issues. It does not mean that minorities and social conservatives do not agree; they simply do not agree on what the priorities should be. And as long as these two communities see their “moral issues” as being more important than the other, the two shall never meet.

rogerivory_187x100Richard Ivory is the Publisher and Founder, of Hip-HopRepublican.com, a blog that delves into urban issues from centrist perspective. Mr. Ivory is a political consultant who has worked on over a dozen political campaigns around the country. He has worked for both the Republican National Committee and was the College outreach director for Republican Youth Majority. He is presently the founder of The John Langston Forum and is the College outreach director for Republicans for Black Empowerment.

4 comments
Leave a comment »

  1. Richard, I do not know if you or someone else took the pictures which accompany your article, but I do note the absence of African-American males in both photos. Your percentages are interesting, I too have seen similiar statistics. The 36% and 38% fail to realize that to get to “here after” they have to deal with the “here and now”. The Jesus they claim to follow got out of His comfort zone and truly ministered. Their churches generally have more pew space than people to fill their pews. To be candid some of these churches have driven young people away, those that remain take on the same mindset as the elders of the church. The face and name may be different but the same traditions are going to be carried on for another 50 plus years. The cliches of how He woke me up in my right mind, the cooling board reference and Pass Me Not O Gentle Savior plus Amazing Grace will continue up to the rapture. To your questions of where those ministers, religious leaders and politicans were, answer they were missing in action and were scared. They still are missing in action but now mouth little platitudes like that is supposed to make things right. Like their Democratic counterparts for the GOP it is all about getting the votes of African-Americans. Once they get then it’s stay out of sight until we need your vote 2 or 4 years from now.

  2. Richard, the sentence describing the connection between the SBC and the GOP pretty much defined why blacks who are socially conservative won’t vote for the GOP. I think the same also goes for other minority groups like Hispanics and Asians who are socially conservative and should be “natural Republicans”, but don’t vote for them.

    You are right, it comes down to a matter of agreeing on issues that may bring them together one day. It also means getting involved not only around election time, but also 365 days a year.

    Tom Kean Sr managed to get 67% of black voters in NJ because he got involved with the broken public school system during his re-election campaign.

  3. [...] Richard Ivory of Hip-Hop Republicans.com shares his views on social conservatives, African Americans and the GOP. [...]

  4. Sadly, I believe most blacks are uninformed. They walk around daily, in a fog. It isn’t there fault. Schools don’t teach their history. So, naturally, they don’t feel included. They know they’re Americans, but feel shut out of the party. They need to watch a dvd called, Setting the Record Straight: American History in Black & White by David Barton. It’s a great place to start and a wealth of information. Schools should teach using this dvd.

    I’m an Independent. I think most blacks are turned off by the GOP is because of the Limbaughs, the Palins, the Becks. No one wants to be associated with that bunch. I mean, come on… you go from folks like Charles Sumner, Lincoln, Harriet Tubman, Frederick Douglass to that batch of sad sacks?!? The GOP should go back to what they were founded on. They started solely to end slavery and for civil rights. They did a great job and got the new country off to a great start. Democrats derailed it after reconstruction. What folks don’t understand is that the GOP used to be 90% black. The Republican Party of Texas was founded by 150 blacks and 20 whites. Most people don’t know all of this. They don’t know that democrats actually started the KKK. They don’t know that Martin Luther King, Jr. and his father were republicans. They don’t teach any of that in school.

    People should just learn their history.

Leave Comment